Author's note: this piece ran in edited form and under a different title at Hemmings Daily. I post it here in original form to share with anyone who asks me about tractors.
When would-be homesteaders find out that my wife and I operate a variety of tractors on our farm, including two vintage models, the questions pour in: what’s the best old tractor to get? Which vintage tractors are safest?
The second question proves easy to answer: none, even if you grew up farming, and especially if you work hilly ground.
As with chain saws and firearms, never let your guard down around any tractor. Many are prone to tipping over on hills, unless the driver learns how to manage such terrain. Some slopes are simply too steep, period.
Mostly we use a modern 4WD tractor with a loader and lots of safety features undreamt of in the 1940s and 50s. Our antiques do light work, a 1951 John Deere M mowing a few acres weekly.
In 2012, we returned to rural property where my wife grew up, and we purchased some of her late parents’ machinery. We already had a decade of experience running most of it. In retirement we operate a free-range poultry operation for egg production. Keeping hilly pasturage in shape for laying hens and livestock guardian dogs requires planning and the right equipment.
Still Thinking of Farming with an Antique? Three Essentials
Many antique machines sell at reasonable prices, especially once-common models. Online forums have members who use these for hard work, so see which problems afflict various models. If you simply want a “parade tractor,” anything would do, even a Lanz Bulldog, a German machine that runs on fuels ranging from diesel to, I suppose, extra-virgin olive oil.
When considering a “do it all” working tractor, however, find a model with a wide-set front end, good availability of attachments, and a three-point hitch for connecting implements out back. That hitch is an early safety feature, keeping the tractor from back-flipping if, say, a plow gets stuck on a root, which I’ve had occur without mishaps.
A clever “tractorpunk” might make anything work, perhaps not very safely. In Maryland I recently saw two Amish kids using a team of draft horses to pull a mower designed for a tractor. They’d mounted a gasoline engine on the mower’s upper deck.
But that’s not most folks.
Green, Red, Orange, Etc.
A homesteader should have someone around to teach the basics of shifting, engaging PTO shafts, doing maintenance, and operating in wet weather. Once you are shopping around, I recommend a 12-volt conversion for a working antique. Ours have that and one has electronic ignition in place of points. The simplicity of that machine meant I could install an entirely new wire-harness while upgrading the ignition. Whatever you get, buy an owners and shop manual.
I include a few models with which I’ve had experience or would love to own. Others should chime in about Massey-Ferguson, Case, Minneapolis-Moline, Oliver, New Holland, (which continued Ford’s line of tractors), and more.
These picks do not have front-end loaders, though I’ve seen conversion kits. They lack seat belts, roll bars, and 4WD, so invest in weights for the front wheels or brush guard. All have a PTO except one and few, if any, have hour meters to tell you how long the machine has served.
So gas or diesel? Even with non-ethanol 93 octane, gasoline engines can be hard to start if left sitting for several weeks. Diesels don’t tend to have that issue, in my experience.
I’ve learned to start my vintage gas-burners a few times during the winter, in consequence.
The Ford 8N
Many newcomers start with this barebones but capable unit. Any entry at Wikipedia that features the word “tractor” includes a pop-up image of the 8N. If you asked a child to draw a tractor, odds on it would look exactly like an 8N, no matter the color crayons used.
With its Ferguson-derived three-point-hitch, the N-series changed farming for many small operations. It was the first tractor I considered, when I saw one in the shed at a friend’s place, high up in the mountains of Highland County, Virginia. He warned me right away, despite the 8N’s low and wide stance, that “this machine has killed more new farmers than anything else.”
The four-cylinder flathead only pumps out about 25 HP, but it can fly in fourth gear. My friend then pointed to a 4WD John Deere that he bought it after a few scary months of using the old Ford on very steep terrain. We later acquired an 8N and have used it for over a dozen years. It’s the very same machine on which I learned to plow and mow, at the turn of the century.
With some precautions, 8Ns can be a superb first tractor. They are cheap to purchase, parts are readily available, and the motor is reliable. My own 1952 model just needs to be run occasionally to fire right up when needed, and I’ve never rebuilt the one-barrel carb (done that twice since 2013 for our John Deere M).
Keep in mind that Ford’s workhorse has two issues that can get a novice into big trouble quickly. The tractor’s reverse gear can terrify an operator the first time it’s engaged. The idle RPMs match that of third gear (a guess, as it has no tachometer). Just imagine backing up fast and hitting something, then flying out of the seat. I’ve learned to shift into reverse and leave the barn with at low throttle, easing off the clutch as it engages. It’s brisk but not terrifying. Practice this on a level area with nothing behind you. You can jackknife a rotary-cutter fast, otherwise.
Be wary in winter weather. Another buddy with an 8N heard of them left out in winter, until the rear wheels froze to the ground. Starting off might flip the tractor, leading to catastrophe.
Another big concern I learned day one: the 8N features a transmission-driven PTO, which means that when you engage the clutch to stop, a mower’s rotating cutter blade will continue to push the tractor forward. This can put 8N and farmer into a pond or a tree.
Were the 8N my primary tractor, I’d be certain to buy an accessory called an Overrunning Clutch, which mounts quickly to the PTO shaft. For under $100, it stops the rotation of an implement from “back driving” to the tractor’s transmission. All modern equipment has such a feature.
When shopping for 8Ns, check the power of the hydraulics. Some are feeble from decades of use and abuse. Ours is fine but nothing compared to modern machines. It also is not a “live” (or independent) hydraulics system. Thus you have to engage the PTO to lift an implement, which adds danger because if it’s a mower, that blade will be spinning! When starting off in the barn I’ve learned to keep the tractor in neutral, lift the mower, push in the clutch until the shaft stops turning, then shift to reverse. On the move, I lower or lift an implement as I please.
A homesteader with money in the bank might consider later Fords with independent hydraulics and PTOs. Some from the early 60s have diesel engines. Still, the 8N’s simplicity means that maintaining one provides easy lessons for the new farm mechanic.
Farmall Cub or Super A
“If it ain’t red, leave it in the shed.” International made the Farmall brand for many decades. I’d considered a Cub for a while. It features an independent PTO. Three-point-hitch kits can be added.
All that said, “Wheel weights!” That was my command to a friend who was running a small organic-vegetable farm with a Farmall Super A. He had a lot of experience in the landscaping and greenhouse business but not farming on that scale. His front end kept popping up, and that screamed “Danger!” to me because he employed belly-mounted cultivators. When he waffled on adding weights to the front wheels, I bought some and installed them on his tractor.
These Farmalls were designed for a farmer and not a shop to service, in nearly all cases. I once helped tear down an engine to replace a camshaft gear. We managed it, though it’s a job I’d never done before.
My only problem with these machines is a unique feature: “Culti-Vision,” which offsets the cowl and engine to the left, so the farmer looks down the centerline of the machine without obstruction. Allis Chalmers’ G, described below, solved the problem by moving the entire engine to the rear.
Culti-vision cannot be beaten for row-croppers. My concern? Again, hills. With the tractor’s weight off-center, one must be extra careful driving across a slope. Go up and down with any vintage machine, though steep slopes may prove impossible. Our biggest has about a 30% grade.
My friend advises a potential buyer to drive a Farmall to see if the steering tracks well. He notes that over time, steering can get vague, and farmers want straight rows. Check the steering boxes for leaks and if possible, worn gears.
Allis Chalmers G (or B and C)
As my wife says, “Cute cute!” when she sees one. The G is a tractor I’ve always wanted to own. I don’t, however, know what I’d do with this farmer’s go-cart except drive around and smile.
I’m sure you could flip it on its back, but it would take some work. The very low center of gravity, carlike seating position, belly-mounted implements, and the rear engine make for a piece of equipment that a novice could learn to use quickly. It features a belt pulley for powering implements but, sadly, no conventional PTO shaft.
My Farmall-using buddy says the G is the best cultivating tractor ever built for small farms and gardens. With 11hp, it’s not going to win any tractor-pull events, but that may also keep a new homesteader out of trouble. A couple of companies still make modern machines based upon the G, some with electric motors.
The drawbacks to this Allis Chalmers? It won’t mow big fields, though I’ve seen a sickle-bar mower designed for it. All these implements are specific to the G. Conversely, my old Massey-Ferguson two-share plow works with both my 8N and 2012 John Deere 3038E. For an Allis Chalmers G, however, you’d need a dedicated plow, harrow, scraper-blade, and more.
An Allis Chalmers B or C might be good alternatives, as they have a PTO but like the 8N they lack independent hydraulics. These tractors can be bought with a wide-front axle rather than the narrow (and tipsy) row-crop front end (two front wheels very close together). Three-point hitch kits can be found. I’ve recently seen a C using a pulley to run a belt-driven corn mill. You can get a sawmill attachment, too. I sold one in my barn to a collector; it looked like a wonderful way to lose an arm.
Yes, people back then were tougher than us, but many of them did not live as long, either.
I just need a use-case for one of these Allis Chalmers; parts are available and there’s a big fanbase for “Perian Orange“ machines. We have one of the company’s final tractors, a 1983 6040 Diesel using a three-cylinder Yanmar (same as in many of the era’s John Deeres). It can skid logs, maintain a dirt road, with carry large loads in the front bucket. But “Beast Allis” is not light on her feet. Pulling a mower was like using a Semi for Uber runs.So if you’d like pre-Kubota orange tractors, look for a B or C (or later).
John Deere New Generation, Before & After
My wife’s grandpa worked for Deere, so our family bleeds JD green. I’m particularly fond of two-cylinder “Johnny Poppers” and our 1951 M utility uses a 1960s Woods belly-around our house every week.
The two-cylinder engine is not much more complex than that of a vintage push-mower. Like many Ms, it runs hot in summer. Flushing the system and adding a new thermostat did not much help. In the hottest weather I don’t overwork the motor; I watch the radiator and add coolant as needed.
After I’d restored the John Deere and cut grass, my neighbor Wayne, a vegetable farmer in his late 80s, came over to tell me that just hearing it run made him happy. My father-in-law bought it new and Wayne, who swears by Massey-Fergusons, missed the pop-pop sound.
You can find a modern conversion kit cheaply to add a three-point hitch, if Uncle Silas leaves you his M. The M’s high center of gravity makes it tippy on hills. I go straight up and down the slope when mowing, as I do with the 8N.
Given its limits, one might consider instead with the New Generation machines that debuted in 1960, especially in diesel form, or something more recent. For those needing a big brute for tasks other than mowing, I like our JD 1250. It only has about 1500 hours on the clock now but was used hard by the highway department. It needs a better cowling, and that is proving hard to find. I’m in the process of getting the hydraulics leak-free. It has a Bradco backhoe attachment and open cab. Even without it, it’s probably too big for a first-time homesteader who wants a do-it-all tractor like our 3038E or even an 8N.
The Case for Modern Utility Tractor
When a homesteader asks about antiques, I usually say “if you are serious about this life long-term, buy a modern machine.” That means a small diesel tractor with seat belts, live hydraulics, a loader, and a roll-over protection system (ROPS in tractor-speak). These lack proprietary software so still are designed for the DIY mechanic.
For our farm, we ended up finding a 0%, four-year loan on a John Deere diesel. The hydrostatic transmission means using the loader to move bulk goods from a pile is far smoother than when using our tractors with a manual transmission.
With the family connection to Deere, Kubota and other modern brands were off the table. These firms make great machines and I’ve had some farm-time in the seat of a nearly new 50 hp Kubota with a loader. It was delightful. Check Hemmings listings before you go to the dealer, though all dealers offer financing incentives as well as cash discounts.
But if the allure of the vintage tractor gets under your skin, it is an itch well worth scratching. Carefully.













